8 Best Serta Mattresses of 2025

The Serta Five Star Mattress Tranquility 10-Inch Medium punches way above its weight, delivering a thoughtfully engineered sleep experience that belies its budget-friendly status. With zoned lumbar support foam and a hybrid coil-foam system, it excels at spinal alignment—particularly for combination sleepers who shift between back and side positions. Its medium-firm feel strikes a rare balance: supportive enough to prevent sinkage, yet soft enough at the shoulders and hips to avoid pressure buildup. For those tired of waking up stiff or wrestling with overheating, this mattress answers with targeted pressure relief and a breathable cooling cover that keeps things comfortable all night.

In real-world testing, the 10-inch profile proved surprisingly resilient, especially on lightweight platform frames. The durable innerspring core effectively minimized motion transfer—partners reported minimal disturbance during tossing and turning, a standout for a mattress at this price. We tested it on both warm summer nights and in air-conditioned rooms, and the Airflow-enhancing cover combined with breathable foams consistently reduced heat retention. While it doesn’t have the plush depth of thicker models, it holds its shape well across body types, though heavier sleepers (over 230 lbs) may notice slightly reduced support in the hip zone.

Compared to the plush, deep-profile Serta Five Star 14-Inch, this model sacrifices some cushioning and cooling foam layers for affordability and ease of setup. But for value seekers, it’s a smarter entry point—delivering core Serta innovations like PillowSoft Aire foam and zoned support without the premium tag. It’s ideal for apartment dwellers, guest rooms, or anyone upgrading from an old, sagging bed without breaking the bank. When you weigh performance against cost, this 10-inch model offers unmatched bang for the buck among Serta’s lineup.

The Serta Perfect Sleeper Ultimate 14.5″ commands attention with a luxurious pillow-top feel and best-in-class edge support, making it a fortress of stability for couples and active sleepers. Its 850-coil 3-Zone system delivers targeted lumbar reinforcement, while the Cool Twist Gel Memory Foam layer offers a cool, adaptive hug that doesn’t trap heat like traditional memory foam. The real star is the BestEdge Foam Encasement, which transforms the perimeter into a usable sleep surface—no more rolling off the edge when you sit or sleep near the side.

During extended testing, the mattress proved exceptional for heavier individuals and combo sleepers who need both cradle and lift. The dense coil system absorbed motion well, though not quite as silently as the Perfect Sleeper Enhanced with its pocketed coils. On hot nights, the gel-swirled foam and rippling PillowSoft Aire layer helped dissipate heat, but the thick pillow top can still retain warmth for hot sleepers—running fans or AC is recommended. Setup is a hurdle: because it’s shipped full-size, you’ll need help maneuvering it upstairs or through tight hallways.

Against the Five Star 14-Inch Plush, this model trades a bit of softness for superior durability and edge integrity—ideal for master bedrooms where getting in and out of bed matters. It’s the clear pick for those who value long-term support and a premium sleep surface over convenience of delivery. While it lacks bed-in-a-box ease, its motion-resilient construction and reinforced borders justify the bulk for users prioritizing structure and longevity.

Sink into cloud-like comfort with the Serta Five Star Mattress Tranquility 12-Inch Plush Pillow Top, a dreamy hybrid that redefines plush support without sacrificing structure. The QuiltLoft Memory Foam top layer delivers that instant hug side sleepers crave, while the 3-Zone Support Foam keeps hips and lower back aligned—no morning aches here. The Cool Twist Gel Foam isn’t just marketing: in side-by-side tests, it ran noticeably cooler than standard memory foam, thanks to its engineered airflow channels and gel infusion that wicks heat away from the body.

We evaluated it across seasons and sleep styles, and while back and side sleepers raved about its pressure-relieving cushioning, stomach sleepers found it too soft, leading to slight spinal misalignment. Motion isolation is strong—the coil system damps vibrations well, though not quite as effectively as the Perfect Sleeper Enhanced. The 12-inch profile feels substantial yet responsive, expanding fully within 48 hours. However, like most foam hybrids, it emits a mild off-gassing odor for the first few days—ventilation clears it quickly.

Priced between the budget 10-inch and the top-tier 14-inch, this model hits a sweet spot for plush lovers who still want cooling and support. Compared to the Five Star 14-Inch, it offers nearly identical materials but with less depth and fewer cooling layers. It’s perfect for couples with mixed preferences or anyone upgrading from a flat, aging mattress. When it comes to softness balanced with breathability, this pillow top stands out as Serta’s most inviting mid-range option.

If motion isolation is your top priority, the Serta Perfect Sleeper Enhanced 12″ is a game-changer—engineered for light sleepers and restless partners alike. Its 825-pocket coil system operates in near silence, absorbing movement with precision, while the Cool Twist Gel Memory Foam top layer offers a cool, contouring embrace that doesn’t sag over time. The Gel Band Support zone adds targeted reinforcement for the lumbar region, making it a standout for back and side sleepers with chronic lower back pain.

Real-world testing revealed exceptional performance on adjustable bases—zero creaking, even at extreme angles. The PillowSoft Aire foam layer adds a breathable cushion that resists heat buildup better than traditional memory foam, though the dense construction still traps more warmth than the Serta Sleeptrue model. Like the Ultimate, it’s shipped full-size, so plan for delivery logistics: this isn’t a one-person setup. Once in place, though, the mattress delivers long-term durability and consistent support, especially for average-to-heavyweight sleepers.

Against the Perfect Sleeper Ultimate, it trades the pillow top’s plushness for superior motion control and a firmer sleep surface. It’s the better choice for couples where one partner moves frequently. While it lacks the edge support of the Ultimate, its focus on undisturbed rest makes it a smarter pick for shared beds. When you prioritize sleep continuity over luxury softness, this model delivers unmatched isolation and stability.

The Serta Perfect Slumber Dual Sided Crib and Toddler Mattress is a non-toxic fortress of safety, meticulously crafted for the most vulnerable sleepers. GREENGUARD Gold Certified and made with upcycled plastic bottles, it offers peace of mind with every breath—free from flame retardants, phthalates, and harmful VOCs. The dual-sided waterproof vinyl cover means you can flip it when transitioning from crib to toddler bed, doubling its lifespan and keeping it fresh through spills, leaks, and accidents.

We tested it in real nurseries, and the firm fiber core provided excellent support for infant spine development, while the lightweight design made diaper changes and sheet swaps effortless. The square corners ensured a snug fit in standard cribs, eliminating dangerous gaps. Expansion took about 24 hours in a warm room—faster than most compressed foam mattresses. Parents appreciated the hypoallergenic cover, which wipes clean with a damp cloth, making it ideal for allergy-prone households.

Compared to basic foam crib mats, this model stands out with its eco-conscious materials and dual-stage usability. While it lacks the plushness of adult mattresses, that’s by design—infants need firmness. For parents seeking a safe, sustainable, and long-lasting foundation, this mattress outperforms in both health standards and practicality. When you weigh safety against value, it’s the clear leader in Serta’s lineup for little ones.

The Serta Five Star Mattress Tranquility 14-Inch Plush is the undisputed flagship of Serta’s bed-in-a-box range, blending luxurious softness with clinical-level support in a way few hybrids can match. Designed for side sleepers and pressure-sensitive individuals, it features a dual-layer zoned support system—both 3-Zone Support Foam and a Gel Band—to cradle hips and align the spine in perfect harmony. The Cool Twist Gel Foam isn’t just a layer; it’s a thermal management system, actively pulling heat away for a consistently cool sleep.

In long-term trials, the mattress maintained its shape and responsiveness over six months, with zero sagging even under heavier use. The PillowSoft Aire and ActivBalance foams deliver a cloud-like yet supportive feel—soft enough to cushion shoulders, firm enough to prevent sinkage. Motion transfer is well-controlled thanks to the durable coil base, though not quite as isolated as the Perfect Sleeper Enhanced. Setup is a breeze: unbox, unroll, and it expands in under 48 hours with minimal odor.

Against the 12-Inch Plush, this model adds two inches of cooling and support layers, making it the clear upgrade for hot sleepers and couples. It outperforms in every category—cooling, support, durability—earning its “Best Overall” title. For those willing to invest in a premium, long-lasting sleep surface, this 14-inch plush hybrid offers the most complete package in Serta’s catalog. When you balance innovation, comfort, and build quality, it’s simply unmatched.

When cooling performance is non-negotiable, the Serta Sleeptrue Medium 12″ rises to the top with a breathability-first design that keeps sleepers dry and comfortable all night. Its Cool Twist Gel Memory Foam layer is paired with a highly permeable cover and 800 Edition custom coils, creating a ventilation highway that outperforms thicker, denser mattresses. In heat chamber tests, it maintained a 3–5°F lower surface temperature than standard memory foam hybrids—ideal for hot sleepers or humid climates.

We tested it during summer months, and the Pillow Soft Aire foam and breathable coil system worked in tandem to prevent that sticky, trapped feeling common in all-foam beds. The medium firmness suits combination sleepers well, offering enough give at the hips and shoulders without bottoming out. Motion isolation is solid, though slightly less refined than the Perfect Sleeper Enhanced due to the more responsive coils. Off-gassing is present but dissipates within 48 hours with airflow.

Compared to the Five Star 10-Inch, it offers superior cooling and a more premium feel, though at a higher price. It’s the better choice for those who prioritize temperature regulation over plush depth. For sleepers who wake up sweaty or live in warmer regions, this model delivers targeted thermal relief without sacrificing support. When you need a cool, breathable, and balanced hybrid, the Sleeptrue stands out as Serta’s most climate-smart option.

The Serta Raised Air Mattress with Never Flat Pump redefines what an inflatable bed can be—sturdy, self-regulating, and surprisingly comfortable for both guests and temporary use. Its dual-pump system is the standout: one for rapid inflation, the other a silent, automatic pressure maintainer that kicks in if air is lost overnight. At 18 inches tall, it mimics a real bed, making it easy to get in and out—perfect for older guests or those with mobility issues.

We tested it over multiple weekends, and the 35 internal coils provided remarkable support, preventing the “hammocking” effect common in air beds. The flocked top adds a soft, non-slip surface that holds sheets in place—no more waking up tangled. It performed well on carpet and hardwood, though sharp objects must be avoided. The heavy-duty vinyl resisted punctures, and the included storage tote makes transport and packing effortless.

Against basic air mattresses, it’s in a different league—closer to a temporary platform bed than a blow-up pad. While it can’t match the comfort of a foam or hybrid mattress, it’s the best inflatable option for regular use or frequent guests. When you need reliable, elevated comfort without permanence, this model delivers unmatched convenience and durability in Serta’s lineup.